THE LAST DITCH

British students' grasp of English worse than foreign counterparts, reveals study – Telegraph.

Margaret Thatcher's greatest failure was in education policy. As it turned out, breaking the coercive power of trade unions and setting the economy free was a waste of time, if not accompanied by a corresponding purge of educationalists. Every student since her time has been taught that she was wrong. The British educational establishment lives in a Marxist time bubble, all unaware that Charlie-boy's ideas were tried and failed across the globe.

In consequence, British education is a machine for destroying human potential and the people who suffer most are the bright children of ordinary families. Labour consistently claims educational progress, but its data are as reliable as Soviet tractor production statistics. The five year plan is always filled and any perceptions that quality is declining are "sabotage by hostile elements." Yet, as the linked story shows, the truth is out there.

The analysis of final year work produced at Imperial College London found that UK students made almost three times as many errors in English compared to their foreign counterparts from China, Singapore and Indonesia.
Bernard Lamb, Emeritus reader in genetics at Imperial and president of the Queen's English Society, found that his 18 home grown students had an average of 52.2 errors in two pieces of assessed course work and the final degree exam, while the 10 overseas students averaged only 18.8 errors.
The UK students, attending one of the best universities in the world, all had excellent A-level results, or equivalents, yet all their written work had to be corrected for English.

As someone trying to learn Chinese, I know the height of the language barrier those Chinese students have crossed. If they can write better English than a native speaker with "good" A levels then, trust me, something is rotten in the state of British education. I do not hesitate to name that rottenness for you. British educationalists are more concerned about agitprop than truth. They are interested, not in opening minds, but in closing them. One of my personal tests of a new Conservative government will be this; if they start with the "tractor stats", I will know they are frauds.

7 responses to “Will the Conservative Government tell the truth about British Education?”

  1. wonkotsane Avatar

    There’s no such thing as British education, it’s devolved. A Conservative government will only be able to tinker with the English education system.

    Like

  2. Tom Paine Avatar

    Fair point. If he tinkered with English education, it would be a start. And when the children of Wales and Scotland were put at a visible disadvantage by their parents’ ludicrous political ideas, maybe they would grow up to despise them as they should?

    Like

  3. Alexander De Large Avatar
    Alexander De Large

    Education is not the business of the state:
    http://mises.org/rothbard/newlibertywhole.asp#p119

    Like

  4. JMB Avatar

    Well Mrs Thatcher can’t be blamed for the degradation of the education systems in the rest of the English speaking world but the results are the same everywhere.
    No one reads for pleasure any more and no one seems to appreciate the fine use of words. English is such a rich language, with wonderful nuances.
    How soon before there is no one left to even recognize the errors? That random thought popped into my head as I read that statement.
    Oh but everyone knows how to write text speech correctly. 🙂

    Like

  5. David Davis Avatar

    the result has been acheived on purpose, deliberately.
    The Scumbag GramscoFabaiNazis have been at it for some decades while our back was turned through having to fix other seemingly more pressing matters, such as clearing up the rubble of Europe after WW2.
    This was deliberate: they, the GramscoFabiaNazis, will never, never forgive us, for fixing people who could have been erazed and who were in their way. Such as Kulaks, self-employed-Jews, English liberal conservatives, libertarians, Americans from North Dakota, Australian and NZ gentlemen and their families, and the like.

    Like

  6. Moggsy Avatar

    Teaching has been weighed down with political dogma that would not recognise an actual fact if it bit them (which they do) probably for decades, maybe since the 60s. Certainly it was like that when I was at school. From what I heard it was particularly bad in teacher training.

    Like

  7. Andrew Duffin Avatar
    Andrew Duffin

    Three times as many errors as the foreign students?
    And this was Imperial College, no less – one of our three or four best universities, not some jumped-up bog standard poly.
    There really is no hope, is there?
    (and to the contributor who thought Scottish education might be better, I’ve got new for you, pal – it’s not)

    Like

Leave a reply to Alexander De Large Cancel reply

Tom is a retired international lawyer. He was a partner in a City of London law firm and spent almost twenty years abroad serving clients from all over the world.

Returning to London on retirement in 2011, he was dismayed to discover how much liberty had been lost in the UK while he was away.

He’s a classical liberal (libertarian, if you must) who, like his illustrious namesake, considers that

“…government even in its best state is but a necessary evil; in its worst state an intolerable one.”

Latest comments
  1. Lord T's avatar
  2. tom.paine's avatar
  3. Lord T's avatar
  4. tom.paine's avatar
  5. Lord T's avatar