THE LAST DITCH

The basic expense data they tried to suppress can now be downloaded here. If you have a blog, please add your own link to the download and blog about it. Please check your own MP's claims and write to him/her about them, politely requesting further details if necessary. Let's make sure the whole country knows, pace their defender-in-chief Mr Dale, just what sort of people have infiltrated a once-honourable calling. Several comments on Iain's "now, now" piece on the subject today are delightful, but the best is the simplest, calmest and most reasonable;

"MPs shouldn't have to pay for their own 2nd accommodation, where it's needed, of course. But why do they get to keep the houses we've paid for?"

Quite. Not to mention the antiques, electronics and other goodies we have paid for. As they seem so comfortable living in their sisters' bedrooms, caravans or whatever else allows them to charge the mortgage on their more valuable personal home to the taxpayer, I would provide them with a dormitory instead. I would model it on the worst ward in the NHS and upgrade it every five years as that standard is raised. How long would those Nightingale Wards last then? About five years, is my guess.

If Iain Dale is adopted again as a parliamentary candidate, I hope he first gives a pledge on the issue of expenses, in particular second homes. His defence of the system (thought not, to be fair to him, any particular fraudulent claims) has put him on the "them" side of the "us and them" divide that this issue is opening up in Britain. Particularly as he has been defending them on points as to which he openly blogs that "he hopes" (i.e. he doesn't know) that he's right. I defer to no-one in my respect for his communication skills, but I am damned if I know why the taxpayers should buy him (or any other politician) a house. Whether or not they pay CGT on a subsequent sale.

h/t Guido

4 responses to “How much has your MP claimed?”

  1. Iain Dale Avatar

    You seem to have completely misunderstood my post. I believe the whole second home allowance needs to be completely reformed. MPs from outer London should not get it at all, and if they have to stay in London on the odd night they should stay in hotels. MPs from further away should get an allowance for rent or mortgage interest. But furnishings etc should not be claimable.
    When I stood at the last election I issued a ten point pledge of integrity which included commitments to publish all expenses in detail, down to the last penny. I also made a commitment not to have any consultancies or directorships, among other things.
    I was the only candidate to do so and got a lot of flak from Tory Mps for it. A fat of good it did me!
    If I ever stand again, I shall do something similar.

    Like

  2. Tom Paine Avatar

    I applaud that, Iain. It did you some good, however; you can mention it now when the politicians are so discredited that many of them may never recover (and new candidates will be needed). If I misunderstood your post, I apologise. Most of your commenters seem to have misunderstood it similarly, so perhaps there’s something in the way you are making your point that’s unclear? You are certainly taking something of a beating over there (where I am sadly unable to contribute because every available form of comment authentication puts up my real name, rather than Tom Paine). People are rightly furious and cannot understand why someone who promises to be clean, if elected, is defending people who are manifestly and disgracefully unclean. I don’t deny that an honest politician is a theoretical possibility. I am even prepared to accept that you might prove to be one. Right now, however, the public has the impression that most MPs of all parties are shabby little scammers. If no-one wants to hear otherwise, they have only themselves to blame (not least for tolerating an egregiously grasping Speaker).

    Like

  3. rech Avatar
    rech

    Why would mortgage interest be claimable? Out here in Reality, no-one gets to claim mortgage interest when they spend the odd night out of town. Maybe there are some companies that would pay the interest (rather than a relocation allowance) if you moved from Hong Kong to Dubai, but I’ve never heard of it. Otherwise you would stay in a serviced apartment. You’re aware that trainee doctors are being told to pay market rents (soon) for their dingy rooms in NHS hospitals?

    Like

  4. Tom Paine Avatar

    I couldn’t agree more. MPs have no-one but themselves to blame for their sleazy reputation.
    Sent from my iPhone

    Like

Leave a comment

Tom is a retired international lawyer. He was a partner in a City of London law firm and spent almost twenty years abroad serving clients from all over the world.

Returning to London on retirement in 2011, he was dismayed to discover how much liberty had been lost in the UK while he was away.

He’s a classical liberal (libertarian, if you must) who, like his illustrious namesake, considers that

“…government even in its best state is but a necessary evil; in its worst state an intolerable one.”

Latest comments
  1. Lord T's avatar
  2. tom.paine's avatar
  3. Lord T's avatar
  4. tom.paine's avatar
  5. Lord T's avatar